Gabe is the most annoying. At first I thought Andy was pretty meh. Then after a little while I started to actually like him and liked him more and more as the show went on. Then season 8 and 9 came along and ruined him completely. He was only good after that in the finale. Overall though I liked Andy more than i liked Gabe. I really hated Gabe and I think he is the easily the worst IN MY OPINION.