Talk:Goodbye, Toby/@comment-74.105.31.98-20150104210049/@comment-34440281-20180214130204

In the Garden Party episode you're referring to, Andy's parents play a major role in the episode with multiple speaking lines. So they probably needed more seasoned actors with television experience compared to the brief role the parents played in this season 4 finale. Also, Im sure they had open auditions for the roles since their previous appearance was so very brief and had no lines. They figured the relative impact of changing these actors would be minimum.