Andy-Angela-Dwight Love Triangle

Season 4


Angela is desperate to find someone to date in "Launch Party", since Dwight is not accepting that their relationship is over after Angela dumps him for euthanizing her cat, Sprinkles, without permission. However, pickings are slim, and since Angela is very judgmental of others, it would take a lot in order for her to be courted.

But luckily for Angela, Andy seems interested in her, and asks Dwight if he should go for it. Not knowing that Dwight and Angela had been together before, Andy keeps pestering Dwight with questions, until Dwight gives him a definite no.

Andy still pushes on, though, and steals an ice sculpture for Angela, who had been looking for one for the whole episode. That plus a serenade that Andy put together for Angela, leaves Angela touched and Dwight feeling more sour than ever.

In "Money", Andy gives Angela a cat that he claims "Came looking for her." This is the same cat that Dwight tried to give to Angela as a replacement for Sprinkles (Angela refused to accept the cat), but Angela seems not to notice and gives Andy permission to ask her out, making Dwight steamed.

Dwight's jealousy is shown in "Dinner Party". Michael and Jan invite the couples of the office to a dinner party, which includes Angela and Andy. When Dwight asks to go, Michael claims that there aren't enough wine glasses and he's a bachelor at the moment. Dwight finds away around this and brings his former babysitter, Melvina to the party along with two wine glasses. Dwight spends his time trying to seduce Angela, who bluntly shoots down his flirting.

"Goodbye, Toby" is a turning point in this triangle. Andy proposes to Angela, who blandly accepts. Then Phyllis Vance spots Angela and Dwight having sex in the dark office when she puts away the party supplies.

Season 5
Instead of telling everybody about the affair, Phyllis blackmails Angela with it, and Andy is none the wiser as he gives suggestions for wedding locations, all of which are vetoed. Every time this happens, Angela goes down to the warehouse to lighten the burden by having sex with Dwight.

In "The Surplus", Angela sets strict guidelines for their wedding, all of which point to Schrute Farms. When Dwight leads the two on a tour, he tricks Angela into marrying him. Angela is irate and kisses Andy full on the lips for the first time, leaving Dwight looking close to tears.

Angela is blackmailed to the breaking point in "Moroccan Christmas" and refuses to do Phyllis' bidding. This makes Phyllis reveal the affair to a stunned crowd, a smug Dwight, and an anxious Angela. However, Andy is in another room, practicing a ditty, and he has no idea of this until "The Duel", where he challenges Dwight to a brawl to determine Angela's rightful husband. In the fight, both men's hearts break when hearing that Angela slept with the other, and they both dump her when they return to the office.

Central episodes

 * "Launch Party"
 * "Money"
 * "Goodbye, Toby"
 * "The Surplus"
 * "Moroccan Christmas"
 * "The Duel"