Talk:Finale/@comment-69.4.207.58-20130517062432/@comment-173.3.158.225-20130522021939

That was cleared up a while ago, remember? In season 7, Toby is on jury duty for the Scranton Strangler case, which is why Holly comes back. In "Michael's Last Dundies", Toby says he thinks the guy wasn't actualy guilty. In the season 9 episode, Toby goes to visit the strangler (named George Howard Scubb) to tell him he thinks he's innocent, but Toby nearly gets strangled, confirming that Scubb is the strangler.