Amy

Amy is Toby's ex-girlfriend, played by Janine Poreba. She sits next to him and Kevin at Phyllis's wedding. Kevin is very skeptical that Toby could land a girlfriend that attractive, especially when Toby says that he met her at the gym.

However, she is seen again at the end of the season 4 episode "Dunder Mifflin Infinity". Toby takes her into the office to meet everyone, and then makes out with her in front of Jim and Pam, clearly to make Pam (Toby's crush) jealous. Her appearance in this episode was in a Deleted Scene. It is unclear what happened to her after this episode.

Trivia

 * At the time of her appearance, Janine Poreba was Paul Lieberstein (Toby)'s girlfriend. They married in 2008.